Sam Doyle starts underground at Carrow Ridge Coal at twenty-four. The board is split on paying for dust controls and health surveillance. You hold the deciding vote, then you walk Sam's working life through the door you chose. In one life he is a name with a baseline. In the other he is worker 4471, one of 412, and a zero in a claims column.
| Left door · deferred | Right door · funded | |
|---|---|---|
| Day one, 24 | A form from the town GP. No baseline. | Baseline lung function, chest X-ray, hearing test, a respirator fitted to his face. |
| The face, 28 | Dust never measured. Fan down for days. One-size paper mask. | Real-time monitor, water sprays, scrubber, fit-tested P2. Nobody cuts on amber. |
| Health room, 35 | Medical deferred. Spirometer broken. X-ray in a drawer, unread. | On time, trended against day one, X-ray read by a trained reader. Physio for the back. |
| Kitchen, 45 | Breathless on the stairs. GP calls it asthma. Nobody links it to work. | Three per cent dip on the trend. Moved out of the dust the same month. |
| Clinic, 55 | Progressive massive fibrosis. Oxygen. A compensation claim. | Clear film. Lung function normal for his age. See you in five years. |
| On file as | Worker 4471. One of 412. A zero in the claims column, then one case in a table. | Sam Doyle. A baseline of 102 per cent, a trend line with his name on it, a nurse who knows his back is crook. |
| Outcome | Dies at 62 of coal workers' pneumoconiosis. | Retires at 60. At 70, teaching his grandson to cast. |